Renewal Pipeline Review
Renewals never surprise CS
Renewals should be predictable and they aren't. CSMs think a customer is happy; the customer's champion just left; procurement is looking at three competitive alternatives; the renewal date arrives and everyone is scrambling. Every quarter has one or two surprises — a $200K account that lapses because nobody chased the AP contact, a $500K account that downgrades because usage cratered in the last quarter and no one looked. Retention numbers wobble on the last week of the quarter.
An hour-by-hour walkthrough.
Step by step.
- 01
Pull renewal pipeline + assemble health per account
Every renewal within 120 days. For each: contract, usage trend, engagement history, champion status, payment behaviour, competitive signals, renewal-conversation signals. All from existing systems; no CSM data entry.
Salesforce · HubSpot · Product analytics · Gong · Zendesk · Stripe - 02
Score + bucket every renewal
Multi-factor score against your own historical renewal outcomes. Buckets: high-confidence, attention-needed, at-risk, critical. Each bucket carries a specific playbook + expected time investment.
Historical warehouse · Scoring model · Playbook library - 03
Draft the CSM Monday-morning digest
Per-CSM digest with their renewals bucketed + the specific playbook per bucket. Playbooks include the exact next actions with time estimates so CSMs can plan their week.
Slack · Teams · Email · CSM dashboard - 04
Coordinate the multi-role plays
At-risk + critical renewals often need product, support, exec sponsor. Rev builds the multi-role plan, routes coordination tasks to each stakeholder, tracks response, keeps the CSM in the loop.
Slack · Teams · Task queue · Exec sponsor registry - 05
CS-leader weekly rollup + forecast
Weekly digest: pipeline value by bucket, top at-risk accounts with story, forecast retention rate vs. quota, week-over-week movement. Escalations surface + resolutions tracked.
Analytics · Slack digest · CS-leader dashboard
What you connect to make this run.
Salesforce · HubSpot
read+writeRenewal opportunity data + contract metadata. Write health score + bucket + playbook status back to the opportunity so pipeline reports show consistent data.
Product analytics · Amplitude · Mixpanel · Pendo
readUsage trend, feature adoption, integration usage. The strongest single predictor of renewal — a customer whose active-user count is trending down for 60+ days is materially at risk.
Gong · Chorus · Zendesk · Intercom
readSupport ticket sentiment, competitor mentions, exec touchpoint frequency, customer concerns raised in calls or tickets. Cross-checked for consistency between voice + written channels.
Slack · Teams · CSM tools (Gainsight · ChurnZero)
read+writeCSM digest, exec-sponsor coordination, task queue. Writes back to CSM tool where one is in use; otherwise CRM notes.
Before and after, honestly.
Playbooks that pair with this one.
Deal-at-Risk Detection
New-business deals and renewals share the same at-risk detection engine.
Expansion Signal Detection
Renewal cycle is often the expansion opportunity too; joint planning saves cycles.
Weekly Forecast Roll-Up
Renewal forecast feeds the total forecast; same weekly cadence.
Answers about this playbook.
Doesn't this over-engineer high-confidence renewals?
High-confidence renewals get a single confirmation task, not a coordinated play. The value is in identifying the 15-25% that need attention, not in adding overhead to the healthy majority.
How does it handle multi-year contracts?
Multi-year contracts get anniversary health-checks + full renewal review 120 days before the multi-year end. Mid-term upsell opportunities surface separately when signals warrant.
What about auto-renew contracts?
Auto-renew is a convenience, not a safety net. Still reviewed at 120 days for health; still coordinated where at-risk. Customer surprises on auto-renew are the fastest path to churn.
Can we customise the playbooks per segment?
Yes — SMB, mid-market, enterprise segments carry different playbooks. Enterprise at-risk always involves exec sponsor; SMB at-risk may just be a targeted email + call sequence.
How does this affect the CSM comp plan?
CSM comp typically ties to retention + expansion. This playbook makes the leading indicators visible so CSMs can hit their targets rather than reacting after the miss. Transparent health scores + interventions.
See it run on your data.
Free plan, no credit card. Connect the systems this playbook needs and run it against a past event first.